Back to the Asylum: The Future of Mental Health Law and by John Q. LaFond

By John Q. LaFond

This present day, American psychological well-being legislations and coverage advertise the restoring of "law and order" locally instead of preserving civil liberties for the person. This compelling publication recounts how and why psychological future health legislation is being reshaped to guard society instead of mentally sick electorate. The authors, either specialists within the box, convincingly show how speedily altering American values ignited very varied visions of justice for the mentally sick. They argue that in the "Liberal era"-- from 1960 to 1980-- americans staunchly supported civil liberties for all, rather for deprived electorate just like the mentally in poor health. additionally, felony legislation supplied abundant possibilities for mentally in poor health offenders to prevent felony punishment for his or her crimes, and restrictive civil dedication legislation made it tricky to hospitalize the mentally disabled opposed to their will. through the "Neoconservative era"--from 1980 on-- notwithstanding, the general public demanded new legislation as a result of upward thrust in crime and the expanding variety of homeless in groups. those adjustments make it even more tough for mentally sick offenders to flee felony blame and much more uncomplicated to place disturbed voters into hospitals opposed to their will. again to the Asylum thoroughly describes how this abrupt shift in from holding person rights to conserving the group has had an enormous impression at the mentally unwell. It examines those criminal adjustments of their broader social context and gives a provocative research of those legislation reforms. ultimately, this well timed paintings forecasts the way forward for psychological well-being legislations and coverage as the USA enters the twenty-first century.

Show description

Read or Download Back to the Asylum: The Future of Mental Health Law and Policy in the United States PDF

Best health & medical law books


Encyclopedia of Forensic and criminal drugs, Volumes 1-4, moment version is a pioneering 4 quantity encyclopedia compiled through a world workforce of forensic experts who discover the connection among legislation, medication, and technological know-how within the learn of forensics. this crucial paintings comprises over 300 state of the art chapters, with articles overlaying crime-solving strategies resembling autopsies, ballistics, fingerprinting, hair and fiber research, and the delicate systems linked to terrorism investigations, forensic chemistry, DNA, and immunoassays.

Legal and Ethical Aspects of Anaesthesia, Critical Care and Perioperative Medicine

Medical judgements in smooth clinical perform are more and more stimulated through moral and criminal matters, yet few medical professionals were officially informed in scientific legislation and ethics, and are uncertain of power assets of obtainable details, which leaves them uncovered to public feedback and the specter of felony motion.

Best Interests of the Child In Healthcare (Biomedical Ethics)

Topical and compelling, this quantity offers an exceptional re-assessment of the ‘best pursuits’ try within the healthcare enviornment; the ways that it has constructed, the inherent problems in its use and its interpretation in criminal situations in regards to the remedy of youngsters. Comprehensively masking either the English and Scottish place in the context of the ecu conference of human Rights and the UN conference at the Rights of the kid, the writer examines a variety of healthcare occasions, from the widely taking place to the weird, delivering an in depth research of laws, case legislation, circumstances and their implications.

Informed Consent: A Primer for Clinical Practice

The literature on educated consent and its ethico-legal value in medical perform has grown speedily in recent times. This specified ebook bargains a realistic description of the rules of expert consent and their software in day-by-day medical perform. Written by way of a workforce of specialists in clinical ethics and legislations, the chapters use a case-based method of elucidate the essence of consent and spotlight the ways that person sufferers and various events can form or even problem the elemental rules of knowledgeable consent.

Additional resources for Back to the Asylum: The Future of Mental Health Law and Policy in the United States

Sample text

The mentally ill are seen by many as dangerous individuals who should be held accountable for their actions and imprisoned like any other criminal. Others consider society's lack of compassion for the homeless mentally ill a crime against desperate and defenseless people. The rapid pace of law reform during the Neoconservative Era in both the criminal justice and mental health systems raises important questions of public policy. How many defendants actually raise the insanity defense and how many are successful?

Thus, at the same time that procedural and substantive due process protections were narrowing the number of people who were confined for any length of time, less restrictive forms of social control, such as work release and therapy in lieu of confinement, were extended to a greater number of individuals. People who did not present a grave danger to themselves or others 32 BACK TO THE ASYLUM were usually passed over by formal systems of social control. The philosophy of deinstitutionalization and the de jure preference for less restrictive methods of social control minimized the loss of liberty while reducing the counterproductive effects of confinement.

As a result of aggressive prodding by the psychiatric community, the law was modified to expand what psychiatrists could tell the jury and to make their testimony even more influential in determining the guilt or innocence of criminal defendants. One way to ensure that mentally ill offenders received the benefits of the therapeutic state was to enhance the chances for avoiding criminal responsibility and the resulting prison sentences. This would require essential changes in the formulation of the insanity test and expanded opportunities to use mental illness as a shield in criminal prosecutions.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.71 of 5 – based on 23 votes