Autonomy, Consent and the Law by Sheila A.M. McLean

By Sheila A.M. McLean

Autonomy is usually stated to be the dominant moral precept in smooth bioethics, and it's also very important in legislations. recognize for autonomy is expounded to underpin the legislation of consent, that's theoretically designed to guard the appropriate of sufferers to make judgements according to their very own values and for his or her personal purposes. The concept that consent underpins beneficent and lawful scientific intervention is deeply rooted within the jurisprudence of nations through the international. even if, Autonomy, Consent and the Law demanding situations the connection among consent principles and autonomy, arguing that the very nature of the felony technique inhibits its skill to admire autonomy, particularly in circumstances the place sufferers argue that their skill to behave autonomously has been lowered or denied as a result withholding of knowledge which they might have desired to obtain.

Sheila McLean additional argues that the bioethical debate concerning the precise nature of autonomy – whereas wealthy and challenging – has had little if any effect at the legislations. utilizing the alleged contrast among the individualistic and the relational versions of autonomy as a template, the writer proposes that, whereas it'd be assumed that the model ostensibly most well-liked by means of legislations – approximately corresponding to the individualistic version – will be transparently and constantly utilized, actually courts have vacillated among the 2 to accomplish policy-based ambitions. this is often highlighted by means of exam of 4 particular parts of the legislations which so much without difficulty lend themselves to attention of the appliance of the autonomy precept: specifically refusal of life-sustaining therapy and assisted loss of life, maternal/foetal matters, genetics and transplantation.

This ebook should be of significant curiosity to students of clinical legislation and bioethics.

Show description

Read Online or Download Autonomy, Consent and the Law PDF

Best health & medical law books


Encyclopedia of Forensic and felony medication, Volumes 1-4, moment version is a pioneering 4 quantity encyclopedia compiled through a global workforce of forensic experts who discover the connection among legislation, medication, and technological know-how within the research of forensics. this significant paintings contains over 300 state of the art chapters, with articles overlaying crime-solving ideas akin to autopsies, ballistics, fingerprinting, hair and fiber research, and the subtle methods linked to terrorism investigations, forensic chemistry, DNA, and immunoassays.

Legal and Ethical Aspects of Anaesthesia, Critical Care and Perioperative Medicine

Medical judgements in sleek clinical perform are more and more inspired by means of moral and felony matters, yet few medical professionals were officially expert in clinical legislations and ethics, and are not sure of power resources of obtainable info, which leaves them uncovered to public feedback and the specter of criminal motion.

Best Interests of the Child In Healthcare (Biomedical Ethics)

Topical and compelling, this quantity offers an outstanding re-examination of the ‘best pursuits’ try within the healthcare area; the ways that it has built, the inherent problems in its use and its interpretation in criminal circumstances in regards to the therapy of youngsters. Comprehensively overlaying either the English and Scottish place in the context of the eu conference of human Rights and the UN conference at the Rights of the kid, the writer examines quite a lot of healthcare events, from the widely taking place to the weird, providing a close research of laws, case legislation, instances and their implications.

Informed Consent: A Primer for Clinical Practice

The literature on educated consent and its ethico-legal value in medical perform has grown speedily lately. This exact e-book deals a realistic description of the rules of knowledgeable consent and their software in day-by-day scientific perform. Written via a group of specialists in scientific ethics and legislations, the chapters use a case-based method of elucidate the essence of consent and spotlight the ways that person sufferers and numerous events can form or even problem the basic ideas of educated consent.

Additional resources for Autonomy, Consent and the Law

Example text

I wish to be a subject, not an object; to be moved by reasons, by conscious purposes, which are my own, not by causes which affect me, as it were, from outside. I wish to be somebody, not anybody; a doer-deciding, not being decided for, self-directed and not acted upon by external nature or other men … I wish, above all, to be conscious of myself as a thinking, willing, active being, bearing responsibility for 109 Dworkin, G, The Theory and Practice of Autonomy, Cambridge Studies in Philosophy, Cambridge University Press, 1988, at p 10.

However, the patient’s rights model is not without its critics. Teff, for example, says that ‘it tends to suggest the existence of an absolute entitlement regardless of surrounding circumstances’,118 and seems particularly akin to a highly individualistic model of autonomy. Couching the patient/ doctor relationship in terms of rights rather than reciprocity is sometimes said to debase the relationship – indeed, it might even be seen as positively harmful, not least for the patient. However, as I have tried to suggest, it is not necessary that human rights arguments either depend on or entail selfishness.

Each can co-exist with the other; it seems counter-intuitive to suggest that even a firmly individualistic form of autonomy necessarily ignores the link between those participating in a caring interaction based in trust – that is, the patient and the healthcare provider. A good interaction would result in the negotiation of a relationship that is more equal, but which would include respect for the individual’s right to make his or her own decisions in a self-rather then other-regarding manner. Certainly, an adversarial model, even if inadvertent, seems unlikely to achieve this, but this is not necessarily the result of attention to the individualistic model, because this model – like the others discussed – is situated within a particular relationship.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.35 of 5 – based on 33 votes